1. The big question about religion

Source 1

WHAT IS RELIGION?

Religion is many 'things'. Religion may be buildings, books, art, food, clothing, deeds, narratives, etc. And first and foremost religion is people. Many people and very different people.
The same religion may motivate, legitimate, authorize unselfish, loving, beautiful deeds as well as violence, killing, destruction, power and suppression of other people. References to myths, to the commandments of a god, and to sacred texts can transform otherwise immoral acts into moral acts and pious sacrifices. It can make worshippers into martyrs rather than criminals.
Religion may manifest itself in detailed rules for how the worshippers are to eat, sleep, drink, love, and organize family or society. Some people live their entire lives according to religious rules and ideals. Others, from the same religion, only use religion on special occasions, and yet others even dissociate themselves from religion or are completely indifferent to religion. For many people religion and nationality, or religion and ethnicity, are closely linked, and to them it is both natural and acceptable to be born into and thus adapt their parents’ religion without further ado. For others, religion is only a legitimate and true religion if the individual has chosen it personally and voluntarily.
Many people consider it natural that religion is a life-time commitment, while others find it natural that free and independent individuals change religions, even a number of times, during the course of a lifetime.
In other words, religion is a diverse and ambiguous phenomenon. It does not easily lend itself to a formula. Religion is what it is made to be, - by religious and non-religious people, politicians, and scholars.

How to define religion, who should define?

Countless attempts have been made to come up with short definitions of religion which can meet both the current epistemological requirements for definitions and cover the diversity of phenomena which, during the course of time and from different perspectives, seem to have something in common that may be called ‘religious’ - and thus separate these phenomena from what might otherwise just be called ‘culture’ or ‘art’ or ‘architecture’ or ‘ethics’. A short definition could be: Religion is a cultural subsystem that is different from other cultural systems by containing a reference to a postulated superhuman power whose existence can neither be falsified nor verified.
Who determines when something may be called ‘religion’? The scientists? The worshippers? The courts of justice? These problems are matters of extreme interest to the science of religion. Today’s multicultural and religious world constantly provokes a scientific, political and legal discussion: what is religion, what special rights are given to a religion or the religious? How is the non-religious, secular society to deal with the various groups of people who for one reason or another can be said to be ‘religious’.

The text is a rewrite of an English draft version of an introduction to Horisont - a textbook for the Danish upper-secondary school RE, edited by Associate Professors Annika Hvithamar and Tim Jensen, and Upper-Secondary School teachers Allan Ahle and Lene Niebuhr, published by Gyldendal, Copenhagen 2013. The original introduction was written by Annika Hvithamar and Tim Jensen